Latest News: 25 Million Dollar Wrongful Death Truck Verdict

BLOG TAG: steering defect

News & Commentary

Ready for Another Recall? NHTSA Investigating Ford for More Power Steering Problems

Ready for Another Recall? NHTSA Investigating Ford for More Power Steering Problems

Here we go again. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has launched another investigation of hundreds of complaints about steering problems in certain Ford Motor Co. vehicles. Can another recall be far behind? With one proposed class action lawsuit already pending against Ford in California over the same steering issues, the car manufacturer might want to brace itself for another round of explaining its actions.

The NHTSA is investigating 508 consumer complaints alleging a loss of power steering assist in the 2010-12 Ford Fusion and Lincoln MKZ, and the 2010-11 Mercury Milan equipped with rack mounted Electric Power Assisted Steering (EPAS). Four of those complaints maintain the power steering failure resulted in a road accident. The investigation, announced by the NHTSA’s Office of Defects Investigation on Oct. 2, effects an estimated 938,000 vehicles. 

Drivers reported seeing a power steering warning message when the failure happened, according to the announcement. Some drivers said the problem was corrected when they turned the car off and restarted it. But many drivers said the problem occurred again after restarting the car. 

Loss of Control

The investigation announcement doesn’t provide much detail about what can happen after the power steering cuts out unexpectedly, but the lawsuit does. 

In Philips v. Ford (No. 14-02989), filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division, on June 27, vehicle owners accuse Ford of failing to tell consumers that the EPAS system in certain Fusion and Focus models “is prone to premature failure during ordinary and foreseeable driving situations … leaving [the drivers] unable to control their vehicles.” The plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on Sept. 8. 

Ford moved to dismiss on Oct. 24. A hearing on the motion is scheduled for February 12, 2015.

The complaint describes what happened when the owner of a 2010 Ford Fusion lost power steering while entering a freeway in 2012. When the power steering suddenly quit, the driver also lost traction control and the ability to brake, causing the car to swerve and hit the concrete barrier on the driver’s side of the ramp, according to the complaint. Both the driver and the passenger were injured in the crash. 

It’s important to note that the power steering failure doesn’t mean that the driver has no way to control the car at all. When the EPAS system fails, the manual steering system takes over. However, “[t]he sudden shock of needing to immediately exert great effort to control the vehicle makes the Defective Vehicles extremely susceptible to accidents when EPAS fails.” It’s easy to see how a collision can occur, particularly if an elderly or teen driver is behind the wheel. 

Little Help Alleged

Meanwhile, the complaint alleges, Ford has been less than helpful when car owners have sought to have the steering problem fixed.  After hitting a curb when the power steering in her 2011 Ford Fusion failed in 2012, the car owner took the vehicle to a Ford dealer three times to have the problem fixed, the complaint says.  But the dealer refused to work on the problem because the steering failure couldn’t be replicated, alleges the complaint. 

To make matters worse, the complaint maintains Ford has known about the steering problem for four years but has continued to make, market and sell the vehicles. “Specifically, Ford has been aware since 2010, if not earlier, that the EPAS system it designed, manufactured, and installed in the Defective Vehicles is prone to sudden and premature failure, resulting in marked increases to steering effort and loss of driver control,” alleges the complaint. 

The lawsuit identifies the following vehicles as having defective EPAS systems: the 2010-2014 Ford Fusion; 2010-2014 Ford Fusion Hybrid; 2013-2014 Ford Fusion Energi; 2012-2014 Ford Focus; and 2012-2014 Ford Focus Electric. “Notably, Ford has never recalled the 2010 or 2011 Ford Fusion—or any other model of Defective Vehicle—and never disclosed the problems to the customers, NHTSA, or the public,” the complaint states. 

Ford’s Response

In its motion to dismiss, Ford argues the lawsuit isn’t a nationwide action because the plaintiffs only bought cars in six states— Arizona, California, Georgia, Illinois, Michigan, and Ohio. Therefore, the proposed class action complaint does not represent consumers in other states, says Ford. 

Secondly, under the laws of those six states, the economic-loss rule bars the plaintiffs’ tort claims based solely on alleged damage to the vehicles themselves, Ford argues. The plaintiffs also failed to plead with the required particularity the necessary facts to support their fraud claims. Further, the plaintiffs do not plead facts sufficient to state claims for breach of express or implied warranty, Ford maintains. 

Finally, the existence of an adequate legal remedy in the form of the claims for breach of express or implied warranty bars the plaintiffs from seeking equitable relief. “They may not be able to recover on those claims, but that does not make the legal remedy inadequate,” says Ford. 

Second Lawsuit

Meanwhile, a second proposed class action suit also bears watching. Two California car owners accuse another major car manufacturer of ignoring complaints about power steering defects.  

Deadlines have been extended into 2015 on class action certification briefing in a lawsuit brought by Toyota vehicle owners in October 2012. Irene Corson and Susan M. Yacks say Toyota Motor Sales USA Inc. and Toyota Motor Corp. have known about an electric power steering defect in 2009 and 2010 Corolla and Matrix models but failed to disclose the defect or recall the vehicles. 

The plaintiffs in Corson v. Toyota (12-08499), pending in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, allege the power steering problem caused their vehicles “to wander or drift from center at highway speeds and/or suddenly veer to one direction during normal use.” Plaintiffs filed a third amended complaint on Aug. 5, 2013, alleging violations of the Unfair Competition Law, Business and Professions Code, Consumers Legal Remedies Act, Magnuson-Moss Act, as well as state statutory and common law claims for breach of express and implied warranty.

The plaintiffs seek a nationwide class of current and former owners and lessees of the Corolla and Matrix vehicles in question. Alternatively, they seek sub-classes involving vehicles purchased or leased in New York and Pennsylvania, according to the amended complaint. 

Sidebar: 

SUV Recall

It’s been a busy year for Ford in terms of power steering problems. 

In May, Ford recalled 1.1 million sport utility vehicles in the U.S. and Canada over power steering issues. The recall reversed Ford’s refusal in June 2013 to recall 2011 Explorers for the same steering problem, The Wall Street Journal reported. The SUV recall targeted certain 2011-2013 Explorers with malfunctioning electrical connections and 2008-2011 Escape and Mariner models with faulty sensors, the WSJ said. 

 

Subaru Recalls Almost 5,400 Vehicles Due To Possible Loss of Steering

Subaru Recalls Almost 5,400 Vehicles Due To Possible Loss of Steering

At the beginning of May, Subaru announced a recall of 10,137 Foresters from the 2014 model year due to a potential manufacturing defect in the floor mats.  If the floor mats are exposed to heat, the resin material used on the underside of the mats can curl and come in contact with the pedals, potentially obstructing the driver’s control of the brake, shifter, or accelerator.  As the NHTSA explained, this defect can possibly increase the risk of a cras

Read more

BMW Recall: 35,000 X5 SUVs Over Power Steering Defects

BMW Recall: 35,000 X5 SUVs Over Power Steering Defects

On the national level, the BMW X5 luxury sports utility vehicle is hardly considered a top-seller. With approximately 38,000 vehicles sold to date, the X5 isn’t even one-third of the way to the successful sales numbers of last year’s top-selling SUV, the Ford Escape, which sold more than 140,000 vehicles.

Read more

Toyota Announces Recall of 2.77 Million Hybrids Worldwide Over Steering Defects

Toyota Announces Recall of 2.77 Million Hybrids Worldwide Over Steering Defects

Yesterday, Toyota Motor Corp. officially closed the door on perhaps the automobile manufacturer’s most embarrassing series of events since the company was founded in 1937. Three years ago, the world’s most popular car company recalled more than 10 million Toyota and Lexus vehicles over defects that caused sudden, unintended acceleration, and cost Toyota a reported $5 billion in the process.

Read more

Nissan Recalls 13,919 Altima Models over Loose Steering Bolts

Nissan Recalls 13,919 Altima Models over Loose Steering Bolts

Automobile manufacturers are often overzealous with the release of new models, just as consumers are sometimes prone to the “have to have it first” ambition. While both of these attitudes can definitely have their positive aspects, they also leave the car door open for the possibility of manufacturer error, which is something that two major automobile manufacturers have both experienced this week.

Read more

Toyota to Recall 550,000 Vehicles Due to Potential Steering Problems, Lawsuits

Toyota to Recall 550,000 Vehicles Due to Potential Steering Problems, Lawsuits

USA Today reports that due to a steering problem, Toyota Motors is recalling about 550,000 of its vehicles worldwide. “The defect involves the crankshaft pulley on V-6 Toyota- and Lexus-brand vehicles — four-cylinder models are not affected,” the news source reports. Of the 550,000 vehicles recalled, 420,000 are in the U.S.

According to USA Today, the auto maker claims that it has received 79 reports of this defect “dating back to 2007.” However, the company did explain that no related injuries or accidents have been reported.

Read more

Recall of Dodge Ram Trucks Addresses Steering Danger, Potential Lawsuits

Recall of Dodge Ram Trucks Addresses Steering Danger, Potential Lawsuits

The Wall Street Journal reports that Chrysler announced this summer it was recalling more than 242,000 of its Dodge Ram pickup trucks due to a defective front left tie rod, which connects the wheels to the vehicle’s steering system. If this defective tie rod were to break, the news source explains that it would allow the left front wheel to “move independently, without control of the steering wheel.” The recall alert explains that this loss of directional control greatly increases the chances of an accident.

Read more

GM Recalls Some 2012 Chevy Impalas and Buick LaCrosses for Steering Defects

GM Recalls Some 2012 Chevy Impalas and Buick LaCrosses for Steering Defects

According to a USA Today report from August, “General Motors is recalling certain 2012 model year Buick LaCrosses and Chevrolet Impalas in the U.S. and Canada for two separate defects related to steering.” According to the news source, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (“NHTSA”) explained that such a defect could lead to unexpected crashes.

Read more

Honda Recalls Popular ATV Over Steering Defect

Honda Recalls Popular ATV Over Steering Defect

American Honda Motor Co. issued a recall in July 2008 involving the TRX 420 Rancher All-Terrain Vehicles that were produced from 2007 to 2008. This recall, said to affect around 42,000 ATVs, was in cooperation with the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission.

The recalled ATVs are also known as the Honda FourTrax Rancher 4X4 and were available in red, black, olive, and camouflage. These units have the Honda name and wing logo printed on the fuel tank. They were manufactured for riders that are 16 years of age and older.

Read more
x
OVER $500,000,000 recovered
Newsome Melton has recovered over half a billion dollars for their clients.
Product Liability Lawyer - Newsome Melton

Please do not navigate away from this page until you receive a success notification.
Product Liability Lawyer - Newsome Melton